Why Did My Mortgage Payment Go Up If I Have a Fixed Interest Rate?
Why Did My Mortgage Payment Go Up If I Have a Fixed Interest Rate?
If you purchased your home with a fixed-rate mortgage, you probably expected your monthly payment to stay the same. So it can be frustrating to receive a notice from your mortgage company saying your payment is increasing, especially when you haven't refinanced or made any changes to your loan.
What many homeowners don't realize is that their mortgage payment often includes more than principal and interest. While the combined principal and interest payment on a traditional fixed-rate mortgage stays the same, the amount collected for property taxes and homeowners insurance can change. Those changes are often the reason your total monthly payment increases.
Understanding What Makes Up Your Mortgage Payment
When you make your monthly mortgage payment, part of that money goes toward paying down the amount you borrowed, and part goes toward interest. If you have a traditional fixed-rate mortgage, the combined amount of those two payments remains the same throughout the loan, assuming the loan terms don't change.
However, many mortgage companies also collect money each month to cover your property taxes and homeowners insurance. This money is held in an escrow account until those bills are due. Depending on your loan, your payment may also include mortgage insurance.
The important distinction is that your mortgage company doesn't determine your property taxes or homeowners insurance premiums. Those expenses can increase from year to year, regardless of whether your interest rate is fixed.
How Escrow Changes Affect Your Payment
Let's say your principal and interest payment is $1,200 per month, and your mortgage company collects another $400 for taxes and insurance. Your total payment would be $1,600.
Now suppose your property taxes increase by $600 annually, and your homeowners insurance goes up another $600. That's an additional $1,200 per year that needs to be collected, increasing your monthly payment by $100.
But there may be another factor involved. If your mortgage company paid more in taxes or insurance than it had collected during the previous year, your escrow account could have a shortage. The mortgage company may collect additional money to make up that difference.
If that shortage is $1,200 and your servicer spreads the repayment over 12 months, you could see another $100 added to your payment. Suddenly, you're paying $1,800 instead of $1,600, even though your actual principal and interest payment hasn't changed.
This is why it's important to review your escrow analysis when you receive a notice that your mortgage payment is increasing. Part of the increase may reflect higher ongoing expenses, while another portion may be temporary to cover a shortage.
What Can You Do About an Increase?
Before assuming there's nothing you can do, I would start by looking at what actually changed. Your mortgage company should provide an escrow analysis showing how much it's collecting for taxes and insurance and whether you have a shortage.
If your property taxes increased, look at your county's assessment of your property. Assessments aren't always accurate, and depending on where you live, you may have the opportunity to appeal the valuation. It's also worth checking whether you're receiving any property tax exemptions you qualify for.
Homeowners insurance is another expense worth reviewing. Insurance premiums have increased for many property owners, and shopping around or reviewing your coverage with an insurance agent may reveal other options. Just be sure you're comparing appropriate coverage rather than choosing a cheaper policy that leaves you underinsured.
If your escrow account has a shortage, contact your mortgage servicer and ask how the shortage is being handled. Understanding how much of your increase is related to the shortage and how much reflects ongoing expenses will help you plan your budget.
What If the Payment Is Becoming Difficult to Manage?
Sometimes an increase in taxes or insurance is manageable. Other times, it adds to financial pressure that's already there. Maybe your income has changed, the house needs repairs, or you're simply finding that the cost of maintaining the property is more than you anticipated.
Before making a decision to sell, I think it's worth understanding whether the problem is temporary or whether the property has become a longer-term financial burden. There may be adjustments you can make that allow you to keep the home. If your circumstances have changed significantly, selling may also be an option worth exploring.
At Mastiff Home Buyers, we work with property owners throughout the Kansas City area who are facing different challenges with their homes and other residential properties. We purchase properties directly, including houses that need repairs, but we don't assume selling is necessarily the right answer for everyone.
We prefer to start with a conversation about what's happening with the property and what the owner is trying to accomplish. From there, we can determine whether purchasing the property makes sense or whether another direction may be more appropriate.
Know What's Changing Before You Decide What to Do
The next time you receive a notice that your mortgage payment is increasing, don't automatically assume something has changed with your loan. Take a look at your property taxes, homeowners insurance, and escrow account first.
Understanding where the increase is coming from gives you a better opportunity to evaluate your options and make an informed decision.
If you own a property in the Kansas City area that's becoming difficult to maintain or no longer fits your circumstances, you're welcome to contact us at Mastiff Home Buyers. We're always willing to have a conversation and see whether there's a solution that makes sense.